Who’s on First? Everybody. Everybody.

Filed Under Sketch Comedy

Hulu just put up the best of Abbott of Costello, perhaps in honor of the recently begun baseball season, because what’s the best of Abbott and Costello without “Who’s on First?” It’s amazing how resilient this routine is. It feels a little long today but the pacing and the rhythms are still strong and it’s even a little dark, with Costello constantly gesturing with a bat, implying more than a little violence if he continues to be frustrated by Abbott.

God damn that’s still funny.

What’s even more impressive is the amount of variations that its inspired (see the popular culture section in the routine’s wikipedia entry), most often as a way of borrowing that incredible rhythm for another concept but sometimes as an example of how something funny can be parodied itself.

Here’s a recent variation, with Paul Mecurio using it on the Bob and Tom Radio Show to play off modern baseball’s steroid problem.

And another recent play on the sketch, this one more of a style parody from UCB Comedy, taking the routine and having it shot as if Wes Anderson directed it.

Of course, my all-time favorite is one that destroys the very conceit of the joke but at the same time plays a wonderful homage to Costello’s performance, from Slovin & Allen’s Comedy Central Presents.


The little pause Leo Allen gives before he goes into the actual Yankee names just kills me.

And there’s a ton more. Johnny Carson using the routine to highlight Ronald Regan’s confusion. Abbott & Costello’s orginial all rendered in typography. A bizarre recreation featuring actors unaware of the routine(!) with entirely naturalistic speaking. And another conceit-attacking version from Kids in the Hall, which eats the routine whole and leaves nearly nothing left.

Perhaps because it had vaudeville roots a while before Abbott & Costello took ownership of it, “Who’s on First” has a similar quality to the Aristocrats joke. It can be told a thousand different ways, in different styles with new targets. It almost makes me contemplate a “Who’s On First” competition/festival. I just pause for fear of beating it death with a baseball bat other than Costello’s.

Posted by at | Send to Friend


Posted by Jesse Thorn on 04/09  at  10:56 PM

These guys do one of my favorites:

This one is my all-time fave, though:

Posted by Robert on 04/10  at  10:17 AM

Credibility Gap (in this case, Harry Shearer and David Lander) do a version with bands (Who/Guess Who/Yes).  I understand the exact same idea came up on “Animaniacs” twenty years later.

Posted by Rob on 04/10  at  03:45 PM

You forgot these guys:


Posted by Dirk Voetberg on 04/14  at  05:06 PM

I like this one a lot.


Posted by Dan Fiorella on 04/25  at  11:06 AM

Well, a topic I can comment on.  I have personally Cannibalized this skit mulitple times for my own demeted means.

It seems great minds think alike:

Even earlier was:

but it wasn’t until I got the whole version up on it’s feet before a live audience to see how well it works:

Which just goes to show you, if you’re gonna steal, steal the best.

Posted by thecitychicken on 04/27  at  11:51 PM

I think you need one of those “honorary degrees” for all the research you do on comedy.

Posted by Wildblue on 11/04  at  09:53 PM

What a great platform to work from.  When its a good act to follow why the hell not.

Make a Comment

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.