Dead-Frog - A Comedy Blog

whats so funny
Riff_Traxtracking
South Park Comedy Central
BlogAds Humor Network

Jan252005

And Then the Mother Fing… Wait, I’m Telling it Wrong.

Filed Under Movies, Stand-Up Comedy

Paul Provenza and Penn Jillette premiered their new film “Aristocrats” at the Sundance Film Festival. The film is primarily the telling of one joke over and over again by comics as varied as Phyllis Diller, Steven Wright and Jon Stewart. The punchline is revealed in the title of the film. But even if you didn’t know it, the real humor comes from how darkly filthy the joke is told, with some versions including incest, bestiality, coprophilla and whatever else the comic can improvise at the moment.

The MPAA will likely rate it NC-17. If the language doesn’t kill ‘em first.

Shecky Magazine speculated that the film is a hoax, but the traditions of the joke are well established. Probably the most famous telling of the joke was by Gilbert Gottfried during the Friars’ Club Roast of Hugh Hefner… the joke never made it to air of course.

At 87 minutes of the same joke over and over again, the film could be close to a Bataan Death March of comedy, but it might be of the Mike Myers‘ school of extended joke, where it because funny because it is so relentless. Personally, I can’t wait to see it. If you want to sample a segment of the film, a link to the “South Park” version of the joke can be found here (highly adult language, you have been warned...).

It strikes me this can be almost a comedic Rorschach test, with the improvised middle section revealing something of the comedian’s own dark weirdness when he or she starts describing the Aristocrats act. Or just a really good excuse to curse. Either one.

Comments

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Top 5 Favorite Comics

Of Dead-Frog Members

Mitch Hedberg
1. Mitch Hedberg70 faves
3. Patton Oswalt63 faves
4. David Cross55 faves
5. Demetri Martin55 faves

See the Top 25 Favorite Comics
Log-In or Register to pick your favorite comics.

Blotter - Comedy News

Got a Tip? Write me at

Jul15

This list of five awful Saturday Night Live hosts can't entirely be proven, since Lorne Michaels won't let the Milton Berle-hosted episode see the light of day again. Which is probably a good thing.

The trailer for Ghost Town, the "Ricky Gervais plays a dick who learns to be a better person thanks to dead people" movie, just went up. That's probably all you need to see of it.

Fox execs think comedy writers are uncomfortable pitching in stuffy offices. So they suggest they'll take pitches at restaurants or at writers' homes. Also, will fund writers to shoot short comedy web vids to test concepts.

Jimmy Kimmel and Sarah Silverman break up after five years. I'd suppose that means any possible bits featuring the pair are out as well.

Jul14

Paul Scheer says there's going to be a third season of Human Giant, they just got to work around Aziz Ansari's schedule, now that's he's a character in the Office spin-off. (Best Week Ever)

Categories

Forum Discussions

Re: Wayne Brady at the Venetian

By: EarFone | On: 07/16/2008 01:15 pm

Re: How to add new comics?

By: Iina | On: 07/15/2008 04:48 pm

Talk Comedy at the Forums



iTunes Top 10 Comedy Albums

All links open in iTunes

1

Dane Cook

Vicious Circle

$9.99

2

Bo Burnham

Bo Fo Sho - EP

$4.99

4

Kathy Griffin

For Your Consideration

$9.99

6

Dane Cook

Retaliation

$13.99

7

Mitch Hedberg

Mitch All Together

$9.99

8

Jim Gaffigan

Beyond the Pale

$9.99

9

Rodney Carrington

King of the Mountains

$9.99

10

Stephen Lynch

The Craig Machine

$11.99

Also available:iTunes Essential Comedy Mix icon

Recent Posts

Links